Fight Genie logo Fight Genie
Back
UFC 318: Holloway vs. Poirier 3Women's FlyweightPrelims
Carli JudiceWINNER
Carli
Judice
1-1UFC
26 yrsElo 1565
VS
Nicolle Caliari
Nicolle
Caliari
0-1UFC
28 yrsElo 1443*
Final: Carli Judice by KO/TKO Knee
Who wins
Claude
72%
Caliari
GPT
65%
Caliari
Elo
67%
Judice
1565 vs 1443
Tale of the tapeUFC averages
5'7" Height 5'3"
68" Reach 62"
Southpaw Stance Orthodox
9.32 Landed / min 1.89
6.62 Absorbed / minlower better 3.16
50% Strike accuracy 52%
57% Strike defense 31%
0.52 Takedowns / 15 6.32
25% TD accuracy 66%
80% TD defense 0%
0.0 Subs / 15 6.3
Small sample: Carli Judice, 2 UFC fights; Nicolle Caliari, 1 UFC fight.
How it ends
Claude: KO/TKO 8%Claude: Submission 67%Claude: Decision 25%
67%Submission
Claude calls Submission, Round 2
KO/TKO 8%Submission 67%Decision 25%
GPT: KO/TKO 5%GPT: Submission 50%GPT: Decision 45%
50%Submission
GPT calls Submission
KO/TKO 5%Submission 50%Decision 45%
Formnewest first
Carli Judice126 days out
W
Yuneisy Duben
KO/TKO Kick · 2025-03-15
L
Gabriella Fernandes
S-DEC · 2024-01-13
Nicolle Caliari188 days out
L
Ernesta Kareckaite
S-DEC · 2025-01-11
Why
Claude
Nicolle Caliari
72% · Submission
  • Caliari averages 6.3 submission attempts per fight - highest submission rate in women's flyweight
  • Judice coming off two consecutive split decision losses, showing vulnerability in close fights
  • 68% striking defense differential (52% vs 31%) becomes irrelevant with Caliari's grappling-heavy approach
  • Judice's 25% takedown accuracy and 1.0 average suggests limited offensive wrestling to keep Caliari honest
Write-up

This is a classic striker vs grappler matchup where Caliari's extreme grappling output (6.32 takedowns per fight, 6.3 submissions per fight) presents a nightmare scenario for Judice. Despite Judice's 70% takedown defense, Caliari's 66% takedown accuracy and relentless pressure will eventually break through. Judice's southpaw stance and 6-inch reach advantage won't matter once Caliari closes distance. The striking differential heavily favors Judice (11.23 vs 1.89 SLPM), but Caliari's 0% takedown defense suggests she's rarely in positions where opponents can shoot on her - she's always the aggressor.

GPT
Nicolle Caliari
65% · Submission
  • Caliari's extremely high takedown and submission rate
  • Judice's limited grappling output and no submission attempts
  • Judice's striking advantage offset by Caliari's stylistic ability to neutralize strikers via grappling
Write-up

Caliari's grappling metrics are elite, with 6.32 takedowns and 6.3 submissions attempted per fight, combined with a 66% takedown accuracy. Judice's 70% takedown defense is solid but untested against such volume, and her striking defense (52%) is vulnerable to takedown setups. Judice has a clear striking advantage in volume and accuracy, but Caliari's path to victory via wrestling and submissions is statistically robust given Judice's lack of submission offense and potentially untested defensive grappling.